The international standard requires all four of: substantial contribution to the work, drafting or critically revising it, approving the final version, and being accountable for it. Someone who supervised your project but did none of those four should be acknowledged, not listed as an author — the standard says explicitly that general supervision does not qualify. Settle this before submission, in writing, because changing an author list afterwards requires signed agreement from everyone involved.
Nobody tells school students the rules on this, so it gets settled by whoever is most confident in the room — which is rarely the seventeen-year-old who did the work.
There is an actual international standard. It is short, it is clear, and knowing it changes the conversation.
The four criteria
The ICMJE's authorship criteria are the reference point across academic publishing. An author must meet all four:
- Substantial contribution to the study's conception or design, or to acquiring, analysing or interpreting the data.
- Drafting the work, or critically reviewing it for important intellectual content.
- Final approval of the version to be published.
- Accountability for all aspects of the work, including investigating and resolving questions about its accuracy or integrity.
All four. Not three. The ICMJE states that everyone designated as an author should meet all four, and that everyone who meets all four should be listed — the criteria are not meant to exclude colleagues who genuinely qualify.
What explicitly does not qualify
This is the part worth memorising, because it answers the question students actually have.
The ICMJE states that the following do not by themselves qualify someone for authorship:
- Acquiring funding
- General supervision of a research group
- General administrative support
- Writing assistance, technical editing, language editing, proofreading
Read the second one again. Supervising a project is not, on its own, authorship. Neither is paying for it.
That is not a loophole or an edge case — it is the central provision of the standard, and it exists precisely because supervisory authorship was being handed out routinely in professional research.
Applying it to a student project
Work through it honestly for your own paper:
| Who | Typical involvement | Author? |
|---|---|---|
| You | Question, data, analysis, writing | Yes |
| A collaborator who shared the data collection and revised the draft | Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4 | Yes |
| A teacher who supervised, read drafts, suggested changes | Criterion 2 only | No — acknowledge |
| A paid mentor who advised on method and gave written feedback | Usually criterion 2 only | Usually no — acknowledge |
| A lab that let you use equipment | None | No — acknowledge |
| A parent who proofread | None | No — acknowledge |
| A programme that charged you a fee | None | No |
The row that causes arguments is the fourth. A paid mentor who genuinely co-designed the study, interpreted the data with you and revised the manuscript may well meet all four criteria, and should then be listed. One who met you fortnightly, commented on drafts and advised on venue selection has met criterion 2 and nothing else.
Make the assessment on what was actually done, not on seniority or on who is paying whom.
Acknowledgement is the right answer, not a consolation prize
For everyone who contributed without meeting all four criteria, the ICMJE's instruction is clear: they should be acknowledged, and their specific contributions should be named — "collected data", "critically reviewed the study proposal".
Two practical points.
Be specific. "I thank Dr Okafor for advice on the coding scheme and for comments on two drafts" is a real acknowledgement. "I thank my mentor for her support" is not, and it conceals rather than records the contribution.
Get permission in writing. The ICMJE notes that acknowledgement can imply endorsement, so the corresponding author should obtain written permission from each person acknowledged. For a student paper, that is one email, and it protects both of you.
Have the conversation before submission
The reason to settle this early is procedural. Changing an author list after submission is genuinely difficult — the ICMJE says editors should seek an explanation and a signed agreement from all listed authors and from the person being added or removed.
So raise it when the draft is close to finished, not when you are filling in the submission form. A version that works:
I'm getting ready to submit and I want to get the authorship right. My understanding of the ICMJE criteria is that authorship needs a substantial contribution to the research plus drafting or critical revision, final approval and accountability, and that supervision on its own goes in the acknowledgements. Based on that I was planning to submit as sole author and acknowledge your advice on the method and your comments on the drafts. Does that match how you see it?
That is not confrontational. It states a standard, applies it, and invites correction. If the other person's contribution genuinely met all four criteria, they will say so and you will probably agree.
If they cannot point to which criteria they meet, you have your answer.
When a programme expects the byline
Some paid programmes expect their mentor's name on participants' papers as a matter of course. It is worth understanding why that is a problem, and checking the position before you enrol rather than after you have written a paper.
A mentor listed without a qualifying contribution misrepresents who did the work. It also weakens the thing you were trying to build: a paper with a PhD student's name on it reads, reasonably, as a paper a PhD student helped write. Sole authorship by a school student is a stronger signal, not a weaker one, precisely because it is unambiguous.
When you are assessing a programme, add this to the list of questions: who is named on the output, and on what basis? Our guide to choosing a research programme covers the four questions worth asking, and free versus paid research programmes covers the wider decision.
Author order
Once you know who the authors are, order them.
Conventions differ by field. The commonest is that first author did most of the work and wrote the paper — in a student project, that is normally you. Some fields list alphabetically; some put a senior author last by convention. Check what recently published papers in your target journal do.
Agree the order in writing before submission, for the same reason as above.
What accountability actually means for you
Criterion four is the one students skip over, and it is the one with teeth.
Being accountable means that if someone questions a number in your table in three years' time, you can explain where it came from. That requires keeping things: your raw data, your analysis files, your coding decisions, the version history of the paper.
It also means you cannot be an author on a part of the paper you do not understand. If a mentor ran an analysis you could not reproduce or explain, you are not in a position to answer for it — and the honest resolutions are either to learn it properly or to have them as a co-author who answers for that part.
This connects to how journals treat text you did not write. OJSS states that papers found to include plagiarism or AI-generated writing will not be considered, and the reason sits exactly here: you cannot be accountable for text whose provenance you cannot account for.
The same principle shows up in how examined research is marked. The AP Research academic paper rubric awards up to 6 points for integrating others' knowledge and ideas while "consistently distinguishing the student's voice from theirs." Accountability and attribution are the same discipline seen from two angles.
One venue-side check worth doing too: Think.Check.Submit. asks whether a journal has a clear policy on conflicts of interest for authors, editors and reviewers. A journal that publishes one has thought about exactly the questions in this article, and is more likely to handle an authorship query sensibly if you need to raise one.
The short version
You did the work; your name goes on it. People who helped without meeting all four criteria go in the acknowledgements, named specifically, with their permission. Supervision and funding are not authorship. Settle it in writing before you submit.
For the rest of the submission process, see our guides to what happens after you submit, responding to reviewer comments and whether your research is good enough to publish.
Frequently asked questions
Should my research mentor be a co-author?
Only if they meet all four ICMJE criteria — substantial contribution to the research itself, drafting or critical revision, final approval, and accountability. A mentor who advised you, read drafts and gave feedback on your writing has not necessarily met the first criterion. The standard states that general supervision of a research group does not qualify someone for authorship on its own.
Can a high school student be sole author?
Yes. If you conceived the question, collected and analysed the data, wrote the paper, approved it and can answer for it, you are the author. Student journals publish single-author papers routinely. Sole authorship is not presumption; it is accuracy.
What is the difference between authorship and acknowledgement?
Authors meet all four criteria and take public responsibility for the work. Acknowledged contributors helped without meeting all four — they collected data, gave feedback, provided funding, or supervised. The standard says their specific contributions should be named, and that you should get their written permission first, because acknowledgement can imply endorsement.
Does paying for a research programme entitle the mentor to authorship?
No. Payment is not a contribution to the research. The ICMJE is explicit that acquiring funding and general administrative support do not qualify someone for authorship. If a programme's terms require its mentor on your byline regardless of contribution, that is worth understanding before you enrol.
What order should authors be listed in?
Conventions differ by field, but first author is normally the person who did most of the work and wrote the paper — in a student project, usually you. Agree the order in writing before submission. Some fields list alphabetically, others by contribution, so check what your target journal's published papers do.
Can I add or remove an author after submitting?
Only with the journal's agreement. The ICMJE says editors should seek an explanation and a signed agreement from all listed authors and from the person being added or removed. It is a slow, awkward process, which is why the conversation belongs before submission.